A Federal Conviction Is Not Necessarily the End
Every defendant convicted in federal court has the right to appeal the conviction and the sentence to the court of appeals — for cases from the Southern District of California, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. That right rests on 28 U.S.C. § 1291, which gives the courts of appeals jurisdiction over the final decisions of the district courts, and on 18 U.S.C. § 3742, which authorizes appeals of federal sentences. An appeal is the first — and usually the most direct — opportunity to have a higher court examine what happened below.
But an appeal is not a second trial. The Ninth Circuit does not hear witnesses, does not receive new evidence, and does not re-decide what the jury made of the facts. It reviews the record that was made in the district court — the transcripts, the motions and the rulings on them, the jury instructions, the sentencing hearing — and asks a narrower question: did the district court commit a legal error, and if so, did the error matter? Everything about appellate practice follows from that limit. The strongest appeal is built out of specific, identifiable legal mistakes — a search that should have been suppressed, an instruction that misstated the law, a Guidelines calculation that added years it should not have — not out of a general claim that the outcome was unfair.
Candor matters here: an appeal is an uphill review. Most federal convictions and sentences are affirmed, and a lawyer who tells you otherwise is not being straight with you. What experienced appellate counsel can do is read the record the way the court of appeals will read it, identify the issues that are genuinely arguable under the standards the court must apply, and present those issues in the strongest form the record allows. That work begins immediately — because the first deadline in an appeal is measured in days, not months.
The First Deadline: 14 Days to File the Notice of Appeal
An appeal begins with a short document called a notice of appeal, filed in the district court — and its deadline is the shortest important deadline in federal practice. Under Rule 4(b) of the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure, a criminal defendant's notice of appeal must be filed within 14 days after the entry of the judgment (or, if later, after the government's own notice of appeal). The judgment is usually entered within days of the sentencing hearing, so the clock is typically already running when a family first calls a lawyer. When the government is entitled to appeal, it gets 30 days.
What Can Extend the Clock — and What Cannot
- Timely post-judgment motions restart it. A timely motion for a judgment of acquittal (Rule 29), for a new trial (Rule 33), for arrest of judgment (Rule 34), or to correct a sentence (Rule 35) moves the deadline: the notice of appeal is then due within 14 days after the order disposing of the last such motion (Rule 4(b)(3)).
- A short extension exists. If the 14 days have run, Rule 4(b)(4) allows the district court — on a finding of excusable neglect or good cause — to extend the time for filing by up to 30 days.
- Beyond that, there is no safety net. When the government objects to an untimely notice of appeal, the appeal is dismissed. Treat the 14 days as unforgiving, and do not assume trial counsel or anyone else has filed the notice — confirm that it was filed, in writing if possible.
At sentencing, the district court is required to advise the defendant of the right to appeal and of the right to appointed counsel on appeal for a defendant who cannot afford a lawyer (Fed. R. Crim. P. 32(j)). A financially eligible defendant is entitled to appointed counsel under the Criminal Justice Act for the appeal itself, and to proceed without prepaying the costs. Those rights only help, however, if the notice of appeal is filed on time — which is why the first call after sentencing should be to appellate counsel, whether that is the lawyer who handled the case below or new counsel brought in for the appeal.
What the Court of Appeals Actually Reviews
An appeal is organized around errors — decisions the district court got wrong. They fall into three broad groups:
Errors in the Trial and Pre-Trial Rulings
Decisions the defense objected to at the time: the denial of a motion to suppress evidence, the admission or exclusion of evidence, rulings on the scope of testimony, and the jury instructions the court gave or refused to give. Because the objection preserved the issue, the court of appeals reviews the ruling itself — and then asks whether any error was harmless, as explained below.
Sentencing Errors
Sentencing is reviewed in two steps. First, procedural reasonableness: did the court calculate the Sentencing Guidelines range correctly, treat the Guidelines as advisory rather than mandatory, consider the factors in 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a), and explain the sentence adequately? A miscalculated range — the wrong criminal-history category, an enhancement that does not apply, an incorrect drug quantity — is among the most productive grounds of appeal. Second, substantive reasonableness: whether the sentence as a whole is reasonable under all of the § 3553(a) factors, a question the court reviews deferentially.
Errors Nobody Objected To
Errors the defense did not object to are not lost entirely, but they are reviewed only for plain error under Rule 52(b) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure — a deliberately demanding standard, set out in the next section. This is why the objections trial counsel made, and failed to make, shape the appeal before it is ever filed.
Harmless Error and Structural Error
Finding an error is only half the work. Under Rule 52(a), an error, defect, or irregularity that does not affect substantial rights must be disregarded — the doctrine of harmless error. For most errors, the question is whether the mistake had a substantial influence on the outcome; for constitutional errors, the government must show the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. A small category of errors is different in kind: structural errors — the complete denial of counsel, a biased judge, the denial of a public trial, a defective reasonable-doubt instruction — are not tested for harmlessness at all, because they infect the framework of the trial itself. They require reversal without a separate showing of prejudice.
Standards of Review: The Lens Decides Many Appeals
Before the court of appeals reaches any argument, it answers a prior question: how much deference does the district court's decision get? That lens — the standard of review — is often outcome-determinative, and an honest evaluation of an appeal applies it issue by issue:
| Issue | Standard of Review |
|---|---|
| Questions of law — the meaning of a statute, the Guidelines, or the Constitution | De novo: reviewed fresh, with no deference to the district court |
| The district court's factual findings | Clear error: highly deferential |
| The sentence, once the Guidelines range is correctly calculated | Abuse of discretion: reviewed for reasonableness |
| Evidentiary rulings and most trial-management decisions | Abuse of discretion |
| Whether a jury instruction correctly states the law | De novo; the instruction's particular wording, abuse of discretion |
| Sufficiency of the evidence after a jury verdict | Viewed in the light most favorable to the government: could any rational juror find each element beyond a reasonable doubt? |
| An error the defense objected to | Reviewed directly — but the judgment stands if the error was harmless |
| An error the defense did not object to | Plain error only, under Rule 52(b) |
Plain Error, Step by Step
For an error that drew no objection, the Supreme Court's framework in United States v. Olano requires four things. First, there must be an error — a deviation from a legal rule. Second, the error must be plain: clear or obvious under the law as it stands when the appeal is decided. Third, the error must affect substantial rights, which ordinarily means a reasonable probability that it changed the outcome. Fourth — and even then — relief is discretionary: the court of appeals may correct the error only if it seriously affects the fairness, integrity, or public reputation of judicial proceedings. A defendant who clears the first three hurdles is entitled to nothing as a matter of right; the fourth is a judgment the court makes about the system, not just about the case.
Guilty Pleas and Appeal Waivers
Most federal prosecutions end in a guilty plea, and most federal plea agreements contain a waiver of the right to appeal. Understanding what was waived — and what was not — is the starting point for most clients who come to an appellate lawyer after sentencing.
A waiver that was made knowingly and voluntarily is enforced: if the appeal falls within the waiver's scope, the court of appeals will ordinarily dismiss it without reaching the merits. The scope is a matter of the agreement's language — many waivers cover both the conviction and the sentence; some reserve specific issues, or a sentence above an agreed range — so the first step in evaluating any appeal after a plea is to read the actual waiver, word by word.
What a Waiver Does Not Give Up
- A challenge to the plea itself. A defendant may still contend that the plea — or the waiver — was not knowing and voluntary, for example because of what was said and done at the plea hearing. A waiver produced by an involuntary plea waives nothing.
- Ineffective assistance of counsel. Claims that trial counsel's failures undermined the plea or the sentence are generally not decided on direct appeal at all, waiver or no waiver, because they depend on facts outside the record — what counsel did, and failed to do, away from the transcript. They are raised instead in a motion under 28 U.S.C. § 2255, discussed below.
- An illegal sentence. A waiver does not authorize a sentence above the statutory maximum, and an appeal attacking that kind of illegality survives the waiver.
- Anything outside the waiver's language. A waiver surrenders specific rights, not all rights; issues it does not cover — including any the agreement expressly reserves — remain appealable.
A guilty plea has consequences apart from any waiver. An unconditional plea admits the facts and generally waives the right to appeal rulings made before the plea — including the denial of a motion to suppress. A defendant who wants to plead guilty but preserve a specific ruling for appeal must use a conditional plea under Rule 11(a)(2), which requires the government's consent and the court's approval and must be arranged before the plea is entered. It cannot be created afterward.
How a Ninth Circuit Appeal Proceeds
Once the notice of appeal is filed, the case moves on a schedule set by the court of appeals:
- The record is assembled. The district court clerk transmits the record on appeal, and counsel orders and reviews the transcripts — the trial or plea proceedings, the evidentiary hearings, and the sentencing.
- Briefing. The appellant's opening brief lays out the facts from the record, the errors claimed, and the standard of review governing each. The government files an answering brief, and the appellant may file a reply. Extensions of the briefing schedule are common, and briefing alone often takes months.
- Screening and argument. Many appeals are decided on the briefs, without oral argument. Cases set for argument are heard by a three-judge panel — the Ninth Circuit sits in Pasadena, San Francisco, Seattle, and Portland, and also hears argument by video — and argument is brief, often about fifteen minutes a side.
- The decision. The panel may issue a published opinion, which becomes binding precedent, or an unpublished memorandum disposition, which decides the case without making new law. Most criminal appeals are resolved by memorandum disposition.
- After the decision. The losing side may petition for rehearing, or for rehearing en banc before a larger panel of the court's judges — petitions ordinarily due within 14 days — and may then petition the United States Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari, generally within 90 days. Both steps are granted rarely.
From the notice of appeal to a decision, a federal appeal commonly takes a year or more. The outcomes are affirmance; vacatur of the conviction or the sentence, with the case sent back — remanded — for a new trial or a resentencing; or, less commonly, outright reversal. Families should understand what a “win” usually looks like. In a sentencing appeal, it is a resentencing in the district court: a second chance at a lower sentence, not a release. In a trial appeal, it is usually a new trial, at which the government may convict again. A realistic lawyer will map those outcomes onto your case before the brief is written, not after.
Release Pending Appeal: The Exception, Not the Rule
Conviction reverses the presumption that governed bail before trial. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3143(b), a person who has been found guilty and sentenced to a term of imprisonment is detained while the appeal is pending unless the court makes two demanding findings: first, by clear and convincing evidence, that the person is not likely to flee or pose a danger to the safety of any other person or the community; and second, that the appeal is not taken for the purpose of delay and raises a substantial question of law or fact likely to result in reversal, an order for a new trial, a sentence that does not include a term of imprisonment, or a reduced sentence to a term of imprisonment less than the total of the time already served plus the expected duration of the appeal process.
For the offenses listed in 18 U.S.C. § 3142(f)(1) — which include crimes of violence and the most serious drug-trafficking offenses — § 3143(b)(2) removes the exception altogether: detention pending appeal is mandatory. The practical result is that release pending appeal is granted rarely, and only where the appellate issue is strong enough that the court can say, in advance, that it is likely to change the outcome. The motion is made first in the district court and can be renewed in the court of appeals. How detention and bond work before conviction — where the analysis is very different — is covered on my federal bail and detention page.
After the Direct Appeal: § 2255 Motions and Habeas Corpus
The direct appeal is confined to the record. Some of the most important claims — above all, that the defendant's own lawyer failed them — cannot be proved from the record at all. Those claims travel a different road, called collateral attack:
| Direct Appeal | § 2255 Motion | § 2241 Petition | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Filed in | The court of appeals (the notice is filed in the district court) | The court that imposed the sentence | The district where the prisoner is confined |
| Attacks | Legal errors in the conviction or the sentence | Constitutional and other fundamental defects — including ineffective assistance of counsel | The execution of the sentence, not its validity |
| Deadline | 14 days from the judgment | 1 year from the date the judgment becomes final | No fixed period, but delay can hurt |
| Evidence | The district-court record only — no new evidence | May include facts outside the record | Facts about custody, computation, and confinement |
Motions Under 28 U.S.C. § 2255
A § 2255 motion is filed in the court that imposed the sentence and asks that court to vacate, set aside, or correct the sentence on the ground that it was imposed in violation of the Constitution or the laws of the United States, that the court was without jurisdiction, or that the sentence exceeded the maximum authorized by law. It is the vehicle for ineffective-assistance-of-counsel claims: the Supreme Court has held that such claims may be raised for the first time in a § 2255 motion even though they were not — and usually could not effectively be — raised on direct appeal, because they turn on evidence no transcript captures.
A § 2255 motion is not a second appeal. Claims that were raised and decided on direct appeal cannot be relitigated in one, and claims that could have been raised on direct appeal but were not are generally barred as procedurally defaulted, subject to narrow exceptions. The motion also carries its own deadline: one year, ordinarily running from the date the judgment of conviction becomes final, with a later start only in the specific situations Congress listed — the removal of an impediment the government created, a right newly recognized by the Supreme Court and made retroactive, or facts that could not have been discovered earlier through due diligence (§ 2255(f)). And a second or successive § 2255 motion cannot be filed at all unless the court of appeals first certifies that it meets the strict standards of § 2255(h).
If the district court denies the motion, there is no appeal as of right. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2253(c), the movant must obtain a certificate of appealability, which may issue only if the applicant has made a substantial showing of the denial of a constitutional right. That threshold screen ends many § 2255 cases, and it is one more reason the motion itself has to be built carefully.
Habeas Corpus Under § 2241: a Narrow Exception
True habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 survives for federal prisoners mainly as a challenge to the execution of a sentence rather than its validity — for example, how the Bureau of Prisons computes sentencing credit, or where the sentence is served — and it is filed in the district where the prisoner is confined. Section 2255(e) forbids using a habeas petition as a substitute for a § 2255 motion unless the § 2255 remedy is inadequate or ineffective to test the legality of the detention, and the courts read that exception narrowly. A state prisoner's habeas petition under § 2254 is a different proceeding with its own rules; this page concerns federal convictions.
My Appellate Practice
Appeals are a distinct craft from trial work, and my practice includes both. I have argued seven appeals before the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit and the California Courts of Appeal, and I was counsel for the appellant in three cases that produced published Ninth Circuit opinions — United States v. Barajas-Alvarado, United States v. Garcia-Villegas, and United States v. Ayala-Nicanor. The three cases, with links to the opinions, are collected in the selected appellate cases section of my biography page.
That appellate work rests on a trial lawyer's foundation. From 2007 to 2020 I was a trial attorney with the Federal Defenders of San Diego, and I have tried 27 federal cases, 21 of them before juries. Reading a cold record for reversible error is a different exercise when you have made such records yourself — objected, argued, and preserved issues of your own, and seen which of them the court of appeals takes seriously and which it waves past.
What I offer a client facing an appeal is, first, candor: an assessment of what the record actually holds, including when the honest answer is that an issue is weak. Where the record supports an appeal, I offer briefing that presents the strongest issues in their strongest form, under the standards that will decide them. No appellate lawyer can promise an outcome, and you should be wary of one who does. If you or a family member has just been sentenced, the most important step is the first one, and it cannot wait: make sure the notice of appeal is filed within 14 days.
Federal Appeals Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to file a federal appeal?
Fourteen days. Under Rule 4(b) of the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure, a criminal defendant's notice of appeal must be filed in the district court within 14 days after the entry of the judgment. Timely post-judgment motions — for a judgment of acquittal, a new trial, arrest of judgment, or correction of the sentence — restart the clock from the order deciding them, and if the deadline has been missed, the district court may extend it by up to 30 days on a finding of excusable neglect or good cause. Beyond that, a late appeal is subject to dismissal when the government objects. Because the window is so short, confirming that the notice has actually been filed is the most urgent task after sentencing.
I pleaded guilty and waived appeal — is there anything left?
Sometimes. A knowing and voluntary appeal waiver is generally enforced, and an appeal within its scope will be dismissed. But a waiver does not bar a claim that the plea, or the waiver itself, was involuntary; it does not protect a sentence above the statutory maximum; and ineffective-assistance claims are generally outside the direct appeal altogether — they are raised in a § 2255 motion, where facts outside the record can be developed. Everything depends on the language of your particular agreement, so the first step is a careful reading of the waiver itself.
What is plain error?
It is the standard the court of appeals applies to an error the defense never objected to at trial, under Rule 52(b) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. The defendant must show (1) an error, (2) that is plain — clear or obvious, (3) that affects substantial rights, meaning a reasonable probability that it changed the outcome, and (4) even then, the court may correct the error only if it seriously affects the fairness, integrity, or public reputation of judicial proceedings. Plain-error review is far harder to win than review of an error that was preserved by objection, which is why trial counsel's objections matter so much.
Can I be released while my appeal is pending?
Rarely. After conviction, detention is the default: under 18 U.S.C. § 3143(b), release pending appeal requires clear and convincing evidence that the person is not likely to flee or pose a danger, plus a finding that the appeal is not taken for purposes of delay and raises a substantial question of law or fact likely to result in reversal, an order for a new trial, a sentence without imprisonment, or a materially reduced sentence. For crimes of violence and the most serious drug-trafficking offenses, § 3143(b)(2) makes detention pending appeal mandatory. The motion is made first in the district court and can be renewed in the court of appeals, but grants are the exception.
What is the difference between an appeal and a § 2255 motion?
An appeal goes to the court of appeals — the Ninth Circuit, for Southern District of California cases — and is limited to the record made in the district court: it attacks legal errors in the conviction or the sentence, and it must be started within 14 days of the judgment. A § 2255 motion is filed in the sentencing court; it is a collateral attack that can rely on facts outside the record — which is why ineffective-assistance claims belong there — and it carries a one-year deadline that ordinarily runs from the date the judgment becomes final. A § 2255 motion is not a second appeal: issues already decided on appeal cannot be relitigated in it, and issues that could have been raised on appeal usually cannot be raised for the first time in the motion.